I recommend major revision

Author: obuz

August undefined, 2024

WebFeb 18, 2024 · Also, according to you, the major revision comments do not all seem to be valid or well-informed. Status: Based on the review comments, the editor has put the … WebSometimes the ideas are good, the results are enough, but the paper is in such a shambles that a major revision will likely only get the paper to the point where it needs another …

What does a "major revision" mean? - Academia Stack …

WebI recommend keeping it under observation. Before traveling, I recommend that planning the visiting place. I recommend finding yourself some new representation. WebI recommend you try the meatballs. I will be recommending the meatballs tonight. Both of these examples are correct. However, “I recommend” here means we’re recommending … smart and final ketchup

What does a ‘revisions required’ editorial decision really mean?

WebConsider these factors when picking your major. 1. Career Prep. Choose a major because it will prepare you for a specific career path or advanced study. Maybe you already know that you want to be a nurse, a day trader, … WebMajor Revision: The principle of the article is sound and it has a chance of being accepted but requires substantial change to be made. This may include further experiments or analysis, the inclusion of additional literature or theory, … WebMajor revisions explained. In contrast, an editorial decision of ‘major revisions’ almost certainly means that the peer reviewers of your work are going to be asked to take another … smart and final keto bread

Journal Said “Major Revisions” Needed? Here’s What to Do

How to tell the difference between "Revision" and "Revise and

http://muchong.com/html/202408/9588181.html WebMay 28, 2024 · After submission, I got a major revision decision from two reviewers. I revised and resubmitted. After 14 days, I received the decision [communication] that both the reviewers agreed that I had addressed their questions and that the paper could be published. However, the editor asked me to improve my abstract, introduction, and … hill city university dunedinWebRecommended reviewers must have sufficient expertise in the relevant subject area. Authors should not recommend reviewers with whom they have a conflict of interest, for example, a close collaborator or colleague. ... Major revision. The manuscript could be suitable for publication after the author(s) have responded to the reviewer comments and ... hill city whalewisdom

"WebBy default, reviewers who request major revisions or recommend rejection will be sent the revised manuscript. All reviewers can access the most recent version of the manuscript via SuSy. A maximum of two rounds of major revision per manuscript is normally provided. If more rounds are required according to the reviewers, MDPI staff request a ... " - I recommend major revision

I recommend major revision

Reviewing: Major Revision or Reject? - George Mason …

WebOct 20, 2024 · 2. Create an Excel file to list the revisions Create an Excel file with four columns in which to list the reviewers’ suggestions for revision. You could label the 4 columns as, “Reviewer,” “Suggestions,” “Response,” “Status.” Widening the columns and wrapping the text makes it much more readable, especially for the two columns in the … WebJan 8, 2014 · – The two reviewers are happy with your modifications, and they will recommend to accept the paper. The decision will be “accept”. – One or both of the reviewers still have some issues with the paper. In this case they will ask for another revision. The decision will be “minor revision” or “major revision”.

Did you know?

WebMajor revision Your article has a chance of being accepted, but the reviewers have requested substantial changes to be made. These changes are expected to take … WebNoun (lb) The act of instructing, teaching, or furnishing with information or knowledge.*{{quote-book, year=1927, author= F. E. Penny, chapter=5, title= Pulling the …

Webmajor revision的回复模板先给大家详细介绍一下SCI论文投稿后可能的六种结果以及它们的应对方案。 1. Desk reject（直接拒稿）：主编直接拒稿，文章不会进入审稿环节。对于这种情况，作者就不要再考虑了，赶紧换期刊继续投。 2. 拒稿：审稿人审稿后，对文章评价不高，或认为文章有硬伤，编辑综合考虑后：拒稿。这种情况由于拿到了审稿人的意见，所 … WebJan 9, 2024 · Often the peer review process progresses smoothly through the steps: A new manuscript is submitted; appropriate reviewers are identified, invited and promptly accept; they provide a report that arrives on time recommending major revisions; the authors thoughtfully revise their manuscript to the satisfaction of the reviewers so that the revised …

Webmajor revision的回复模板先给大家详细介绍一下SCI论文投稿后可能的六种结果以及它们的应对方案。 1. Desk reject（直接拒稿）：主编直接拒稿，文章不会进入审稿环节。对于 … WebHere are essential steps to help take your article from the revisions stage toward acceptance. 1. Understand the reviews and suggested revisions. Start by carefully reading the editor’s comments, the suggested revisions and the reviewers' comments. Make a comprehensive list of all the editor’s and reviewers' comments and suggestions.

WebWhen revising your manuscript and responding to peer review comments you must: Thank the reviewers and editors for their time and comments. Address all points raised by the …

WebAssess and recommend After you accept the invitation, you are expected to assess the paper and make one of the following recommendations: Accept Accept with Minor Revision Reject/Resubmit with Major Revision Reject/Submit to Another Journal Reject (without further consideration) The guideline for each recommendation option is described below. smart and final king roadWebMajor revisions are almost always sent back to reviewers for a re-review to determine whether the comments have been addressed and no new comments are raised. If authors are unable to satisfactorily address the comments, further revisions may be required or the paper may be rejected. smart and final job opportunitiesWebMar 13, 2024 · Major revision: The paper could be accepted after some significant changes. This means it’s going to be a second round of revision. This is the most common output from good journals. It happens in approximately 50% of submissions. The whole process looks as follows: Accept Reject Minor Revision Major Revision Submit Research Paper smart and final la cienega blvdWebOne recommended major revision, two recommended minor revision, and one recommended acceptance.) I know that revisions, both major and minor, hint at a higher chance of acceptance. Revise and resubmit, however, is likely followed by a rejection. So I'm wondering which one this response is. THANKS!! Vote 9 9 comments Best Add a Comment smart and final ketchup packetsWebMajor Revision: The principle of the article is sound and it has a chance of being accepted but requires substantial change to be made. This may include further experiments or … hill city vacation cabinsWebJan 9, 2024 · The major results may not be identified from the presented figures and tables. Graphs may be presented with axes labled with print too small to be read. The Discussion … hill city visitors centerWebRecommending Revision. Where improvements are needed, a recommendation for major or minor revision is typical. You may also choose to state whether you opt in or out of the … hill cki